With Neapolitan Ice Cream: The Musical, Toronto storyteller Loredana Cunti revisits immigration history through the songs and memories she grew up with.
Imagine leaving Italy at 16 to meet your fiancé in Canada, only to discover your ship has taken you somewhere else — you’re in Scotland, you know nobody, and the person you were supposed to marry is an ocean away.
It’s a terrible start to a new life. It’s also where Loredana Cunti’s show begins.

Neapolitan Ice Cream: The Musical follows Caterina, a young woman from Naples who is tricked and left on the Scottish coast with only a few belongings, along with her grandmother’s pouch of cocoa. The idea is based on accounts of Italian emigrants who were abandoned in Scotland or Wales instead of North America in the early 1900s.
For Cunti, it’s personal. Her parents came to Canada in the 1960s, and she grew up in Kleinburg listening to family stories and the Neapolitan songs her grandmother loved to sing.

Cunti has worked in entertainment for more than 30 years, including programming roles with PolyGram Filmed Entertainment and Universal Studios. She has also written children’s books and studied pastry-making at Le Cordon Bleu in Paris.
She wasn’t a trained musician, but she knew the songs she wanted to use. Inspired partly by Mamma Mia!, she built Caterina’s story around familiar songs, such as O Sole Mio and Santa Lucia, along with operatic favourites. The music is performed live, with English narration carrying the story.
The three ice cream flavours also reflect the different parts of Caterina’s experience. There is bitterness in what happened to her, the uncertainty of starting from nothing and the unexpected sweetness of falling in love.
It is a simple idea, and a memorable one.
Her production brings performers from different generations together, allowing younger musicians to take part in material that has been enjoyed for decades. It makes for an interesting meeting of past and present, particularly when the songs are familiar to older listeners but entirely new to someone in the audience.
In Scotland, Caterina puts her grandmother’s cocoa to use, combining it with local cream and strawberries to make ice cream. A Scottish fisherman who brings her berries also brings the possibility of love, though her fiancé is still waiting in Canada.
Should she hold on to the life she planned or make a new one where she is?
For Cunti, the musical is also a way to keep old songs and family stories alive for younger generations. The show runs about 65 minutes, with four live performers and projected images, and she hopes to bring it to more Canadian communities.

Caterina’s story is fictional, but the experiences that inspired her were real. People left Italy expecting one future and found themselves living another. They worked, married, raised children and made communities in places they hadn’t intended to visit, much less call home.
After the performance, audience members are invited to share a scoop of Neapolitan ice cream, all adding up to a pretty tasty evening at the theatre.
Neapolitan Ice Cream: The Musical will be presented at the Joseph D. Carrier Art Gallery at Columbus Centre in Toronto on November 13, 2026.

